Shaming Men to Death: Judges 8-9

Some of you know that I’m reading through Judges right now–and some of you are reading along with me, which is a real treat. Today I have just a short tale from Judges, starting in chapter 8.

Abimelech is one of the sons of Gideon (my very favorite story that Mrs. Bradley ever put up on the Good News Club Flannelgram). His mother is a concubine (a pattern we’ll keep seeing in Judges), and, on his father’s side, he has 70 brothers. He convinces his uncles that he should rule over them, arguing that it would be better if they were ruled by one man (him) rather than by 70 (his brothers), and they accept it. He then slaughters all of his brothers but one, thereby mostly eliminating competition for the legitimacy of his rule. His youngest brother escapes, only to deliver a curse on him and all those who have appointed him king. They’ve chosen, he tells them in a parable, to be ruled by a bramble bush rather than an olive or fig tree, and that will bring disaster. You can’t expect a man who cheated his way into power, destroying relationships and disrespecting his family, to be good leader.

Abimelech is a violent leader, always pushing for more power, even when it means harming his own, and he uses deception to win. In an effort to take the city of Shecham, he pushes through the city gates, slaughtering those behind its walls. He approaches a fortified tower where the last of the resistance has gathered, but, as he prepares to attack, a woman hurls a millstone from the top of the tower, injuring but not killing him. Recognizing that he is dying, he asks his armor-bearer to kill him with the young man’s own sword, lest, he worries, “lest men say of me, ‘A woman killed him.'”

What do we learn here?

  • that those who live by the sword die by the sword
  • that those who elect men of dishonor to rule over them will be ruled dishonorably
  • that those who support a strongman who promises them power will eventually lose it
  • that men are so fearful of losing to women that they would rather die than risk being nursed back to health and having to live with the shame of their injury at women’s hands
  • that men recognize this fear in each other as reasonable, because they know how fragile and violent toxic masculinity is

What else?



Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s